Skip to content

Recover research artifacts and reproduce results without changing the manuscript - #4

Merged
HyTruongSon merged 4 commits into
mainfrom
codex/reproduction-and-releases
Nov 2, 2026
Merged

HyTruongSon merged 4 commits into
mainfrom
codex/reproduction-and-releases

Conversation

@HyTruongSon

@HyTruongSon HyTruongSon commented Nov 2, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

The original three primary checkpoints remain missing. This PR recovers the available journal artifacts, retrains only the required primary ensemble under fresh identities, and adds reproducibility/release tooling while preserving every manuscript and historical result file.

  • Recovered 132 unique best states (150 study references), plus 48 resume files. Trained three primary replacements once with original source/validation splits, scalers, architecture and stopping rules. All predeclared external ensemble agreement criteria pass; originals remain explicitly missing and the original doctor rejects replacements.
  • Exact molecular/geometry replay: 22,500 runs and 3.375 million primary per-gene values pass rtol=atol=1e-10. Actual recovered-weight GCN/local inference on all 22 Bassiouni sections reproduces all 792 residual-route reference rows. Reports retain seed variation, rounded targets, initial runtime sensitivity and partial verification of unselected trials.
  • Published research-artifacts-v1: 99 public best heads (3 replacements +96 recovered ResNet18-based), 48 additional resume files, configs/scalers, numerical exports, hashes and instructions. Fifteen assets total 706,647,760 bytes, with all public URLs checked without credentials. The tag is tested commit 44918ef on this unmerged branch; the later commit adds publication/clean-checkout receipts and their auditable driver, without changing packaged training/inference code.
  • Clean GitHub checkout: downloaded and verified all 14 initial draft assets; restored every indexed member; safely loaded all 147 public PT files; ran all 96 recovered public heads on a real 554-location section and the replacements on eight real image patches using a freshly downloaded official encoder. Fresh/cached features match exactly. The existing pinned environment on the same machine was reused; independent hardware/environment replication is not claimed.
  • Metadata-only Phikon rights-review draft: 36 verified Phikon heads and their derivative archives remain local. No such binary was uploaded. Compatibility/permission under the custom Owkin terms and HEST obligations needs clarification; exact sources and checksums are documented.

Validation: 168 tests pass (142 original +26 new), along with all 29 publication targets/71 regression checks. All 83,136 frozen scientific/history files and original scientific Git trees are byte-identical. No manuscript, supplement, figure, table, bibliography, PDF or reported number was changed or rebuilt in place. No paid computing service was used.

Review entry points: docs/RELEASES.md; reproduction/REPRODUCTION_REPORT.md, INVENTORY.csv, RESULTS_COMPARISON.csv, RELEASE_ASSETS.json, RELEASE_VERIFICATION.json, PUBLIC_AVAILABILITY.json and PRESERVATION_REPORT.json.

Leave this draft PR unmerged for author review. Main remains 67738be.

@HyTruongSon
HyTruongSon marked this pull request as ready for review November 2, 2026 04:32
@HyTruongSon
HyTruongSon merged commit 9de7781 into main Nov 2, 2026
2 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant