Repository navigation
This is a bad idea... #21
Description
What I'm going to say is my opinion and only mine.
This is a bad idea...
- You lost readability of your commits in environments where emojis are not readable, which represents a lot of environments!
- Readers must learn the meaning of an emoji instead of just reading a more-efficient keyword.
... full of bad ideas
- Not only you have to learn the meaning of the emojis, but it changes depending on the tools !
🐘 :elephant: PostgreSQL Database specific (Migrations, Scripts, Extensions, ...)
🐬 :dolphin: MySQL Database specific (Migrations, Scripts, Extensions, ...)
🍃 :leaves: MongoDB Database specific (Migrations, Scripts, Extensions, ...)
🏦 :bank: Generic Database specific (Migrations, Scripts, Extensions, ...)
🐳 :whale: Docker Configuration
- If it is not enough, you encourage users to extend the lists!
- You force to add at least one emoji, which means that you think about putting plenty of them, which takes a lot of place if not translated!
:emoji1: :emoji2: Subject
- There are some contradictions in your guide:
All WIP(Work In Progress) Commits MUST have the WIP Emoji(see below).
...
All WIP Commits Should be Avoided!.
- While the WIP commit is obviously a residual mistake, I should mention that you authorize to commit bugs!!
🐛 :bug: when reporting a bug, with @FIXMEComment Tag
I thus think one should not follow this guideline, or at least not in its current state.
Reacted by Daniel Hoelbling-Inzko, Fabian Beiner, Anton Antonov, Vojtech Kral, Guillaume Cornut, Lukas Zorich, Michael Beckemeyer, uzantnomo, Pierre Dupuis 井磊, doomy [archive] and 4 more
Reacted by Robert Ressl
Reacted by Andres Felipe Bayona and Robert Ressl
Reacted by Phillip Copley, Guillaume Cornut and doomy [archive]
Activity
lucadevitis-msm commentedon Jun 19, 2017
Let me get this straight, you opened an issue on a project to express your opinions on why people shouldn't use this project. Couldn't you just avoid to use it and write a blog post in your blog to express your opinions? Open a project in your space to offer an alternative, seems another sensible Idea. This issue looks more like a publicity stunt, or an attempt to troll a simple good effort on improoving team comunication by getting the best out of our tool, includin git commit messages.
pidupuis commentedon Jun 19, 2017
You seem offended and I apologize for that. But you are wrong about my motives.
This is not just about opinion. I also took the time to list some ways of improvement despite the fact that I will not use your guide. I'm pretty sure that's what issues are for...